Back at the house a woman is at the door. Vivien sees through the peephole that the Fiona's scalp is bloody, and she demands help, but a suspicious Vivien does not let her in. Vivien attempts to call the police, but her phone is nowhere to be found. The intruder enters Violet's room as she searches for her phone to call 911. Vivien threatens the now masked woman through the door, but a third intruder is already behind her.

Downstairs, the three intruders, Bianca, Fiona and a man named Dallas unmask themselves in front of a captive Vivien and Violet. They intend to re-enact the 1968 murders of Gladys and Maria and have brought the bowl that R. Franklin had used. Violet is assigned to play the role of Gladys and be drowned in the tub upstairs but she resists and manages to briefly escape to the kitchen where she is found by Tate. Tate tells her that she must get the intruders to the basement where they will be dealt with.

In the music room, a bound Vivien spies Addy behind him and subtly tries to tell her to get help. Her captor turns, but does not see Addy.

Upstairs, Fiona is filling the tub while Violet is forced to dress in the nurse's garb. Bianca enters while eating the toxic cupcake. She starts to feel the effects immediately and backs out, heading for a bathroom. Violet waylays Fiona's plans, informing her that the tub used in the drowning was moved to the basement in a remodel.